Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Elizabeth Lima's avatar

um hi can I please preorder that book of Christy's Reflections on the Amy Sherman-Palladino Universe? I love both these shows but agree that some of the messages seem really off. I do think TMMM ended on a slightly more self-reflective note than GG, both on the feminist taking back of the manic pixi dream girl ("not everyone's going to get me...and that's fine" ...also her kids being critical of her whole schtick later in life), and on the second wave feminism (that last scene where she's rich and famous, but wandering alone through that great big apartment...). Also, after rage-quitting two shows recently for their you-go-girl depictions of abortion, I thought TMMMdid a better job with that plot-line than I would have expected. Depicting Joel's devastation and the ripple effects on his parents, for instance - not a sympathetic viewpoint you often get from the pro-choice crowd!

anyway, yes please to the Christy manifesto on this - or better yet a big zoom conference call where you and all your followers can work out our complicated feelings about these shows!

Expand full comment
Nell O’Leary's avatar

Really love this on prayer!!!

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts